Mama's Custom Cookies – Custom Cookies for Any Occasion – Social & Corporate Events & Celebrations – Shipping Nationwide from Long Island New York

Custom Cookies for
Your Special Occasions

Savor the flavor of carefully crafted cookies that engage all of your senses, evoke cherished memories, and bring your celebrations to life.

View the Gallery

Crafting Sweet Treats
Driven by Passion

We set out to create cookies that harmonize flavor and aesthetics — distinctive cookies that taste as good as they look.

Shop Now

Brands We’ve Worked With

Screen+Shot+2022-03-01+at+8.16.23+AM-1920w

5ed97c67c917b86429019e61_Versace+1-1920w

Love at First Bite

Hello, I’m Debbi Donelson, proud owner and operator of Mama’s Custom Cookies.

As a graduate of the French Culinary Institute and a longtime café owner with over 20 years of experience, I’ve dedicated my career to creating memorable food experiences. I’m excited to lead this next chapter, working alongside the same exceptional team whose creativity and care have always defined Mama’s. Baking has always been at the heart of what I love, and this new journey allows me to fully embrace that passion.

At Mama’s Custom Cookies, we specialize in designing beautifully personalized cookies for every occasion. Whether you’re searching for a unique party favor, a thoughtful gift, a standout promotional item, or a distinctive corporate treat, we’re here to create something truly unforgettable.

Our hope is that every cookie we make brings you as much joy as it brings us. Thank you for allowing Mama’s Custom Cookies to be part of your most meaningful moments. Stay tuned, as we look forward to introducing even more baked goods soon, all with a signature Mama’s twist.

Discover Custom Assortments

Hey Ma, They Really Love Us!

“

Mama’s Cookies were a hit at our product launch. Clients loved them, and the detail was incredible. Professional from start to finish!

- Marketing Director – Beauty Brand

“

I love Mama’s Custom Cookies! My baby’s first birthday cookies were beautiful as expected. I ordered here once before for my baby shower and the cookies were perfect then too! They don’t just look amazing, they actually taste amazing too which isn’t always the case for other places. Their customer service is great, they always respond in a timely manner and make sure they have every detail. I would never go anywhere else. I will continue to order here for all of my future events. (Macarons pictured are from a different place)

- Olivia

“

Highly recommended for specialized cookies to make your event more memorable! The team did 2 events for me related to an engagement. The cookies were elegant and delicious! Looking forward to my next celebration and another specialized order from Mamas!

- Patricia

“

This is the third time using Mama’s Custom Cookies. They listened to what I wanted and made beautiful cookies for my daughter in laws bridal shower! Everyone loved the cookies! I highly recommend this place!